I’ve heard it referred to as “The worst negates the bad” fallacy.

You might be interested to know this scene is a homage to the Looney Toons short, Feed the Kitty (apologies for the YT link)

Surely there’s an outlier. A record-breaking “oldest” dog older than-- Nope

My username comes from “pemptagonist,” the fifth most important character in a play (after protagonist, deuteragonist, etc). I thought it was funny, but maybe there’s something in that because I don’t trust my luck one bit.