• 0 Posts
  • 14 Comments
Joined 6 days ago
cake
Cake day: September 27th, 2026

help-circle
  • It seems to me that what’s happened in recent years is individual companies that offer some sort of information service have been centralizing and gatekeeping

    I thought that’s what you meant but your statement that the fediverse “trying to layer some order over a decentralized physical infrastructure” is totally removed from that.


    BTW I’m not cynical about AI, I’m against it. There’s a difference.
    Were Luddites “cynical” about mechanical weaving? I don’t think so, but the people who called them Luddites in the first place certainly were.





  • Yes, the internet is decentralised in every way, not only its infrastructure. Even unorganised. If that’s your big discovery, I respect that. But…

    the library was the main source of human knowledge, and it was very organized through the Dewey Decimal System

    Not all of humanity uses the DD system.

    Today, even the search engines are failing us, and we are turning to AI.

    This simply isn’t true, and everything you write after that. It’s an insult to actual librarians.
    There is no “Artifical Intelligence”.

    Indexing the internet is a big job. We had data centers even before A-not-I. And people were complaining about how much energy they use. Had we known then how much worse this is going to get very soon…

    Artificial Unintelligence does not do that job better btw. It doesn’t do the indexing at all. It just wastes energy. And, as another commenter pointed out, it actively makes the situation you describe worse.