We accept how people anthropomorphize basic machines, but when they fall for more sophisticated things like LLMs we call them dumb. Blame the human brain, it’s wired to be that way.
Also blame the corporate greed that ruined what could have been a good tool if developed responsibly.
I don’t have a rational reason for this, but I think anthropomorphizing machines makes more sense on an emotional level for dumb machines than for smart ones. Kind of like the brave little toaster, or Wall-E going against the space ship’s autopilot. I guess part of it might be that we see the limitations dumb machines have and it reminds us about our own flaws and limitations, which makes us empathize with a Roomba more than with Alexa or ChatGPT.
Difference is they don’t believe the vacuum is sentient, but llms use natural language in a form where we already accepted the text came from a human before now
I don’t think they are sentient, but there is definitely some sort of evil involved. I’m not sure if they themselves are the source of evil or they are acting as some sort of portal that lets evil into our world.
We accept how people anthropomorphize basic machines, but when they fall for more sophisticated things like LLMs we call them dumb. Blame the human brain, it’s wired to be that way.
Also blame the corporate greed that ruined what could have been a good tool if developed responsibly.
I don’t have a rational reason for this, but I think anthropomorphizing machines makes more sense on an emotional level for dumb machines than for smart ones. Kind of like the brave little toaster, or Wall-E going against the space ship’s autopilot. I guess part of it might be that we see the limitations dumb machines have and it reminds us about our own flaws and limitations, which makes us empathize with a Roomba more than with Alexa or ChatGPT.
Difference is they don’t believe the vacuum is sentient, but llms use natural language in a form where we already accepted the text came from a human before now
I mean… printers are absolutely sentient, and evil.
I don’t think they are sentient, but there is definitely some sort of evil involved. I’m not sure if they themselves are the source of evil or they are acting as some sort of portal that lets evil into our world.
I think embodiment plays a larger role. We anthropomorphize physical things.
The reverse of this, people often dehumanize other people when interacting with them virtually.